fbpx
Skip to content
Home » Blog » The Abstinence Myth in Treatment

The Abstinence Myth in Treatment

abstinence violation effect psychology

Recognizing the factors that contributed to the lapse, such as stressors or triggers, helps individuals to develop strategies and techniques to navigate similar challenges in the future. The AVE process typically involves a triggering event or cue, such as encountering a tempting situation, feeling stressed, or experiencing a moment of weakness. This cue leads to a cognitive conflict, as the individual struggles between their desire to maintain abstinence and the urge to engage in the prohibited behavior. If the person succumbs to the urge and violates their self-imposed rule, the Abstinence Violation Effect is activated. Using these metrics, we at IGNTD are moving away from the black-or-white thinking of abstinence versus non-abstinence. We aim to improve our clients’ overall quality of life, and we never evaluate them solely on their substance use.

Social Media+ Society

  • This preparation can empower a client to avoid relapse altogether or to lessen the impact of relapse if it occurs.
  • Irrespective of study design, greater integration of distal and proximal variables will aid in modeling the interplay of tonic and phasic influences on relapse outcomes.

If you haven’t been in a gym in a while, it might help to schedule a session with a trainer. I constantly tell my students that going to a tutor or academic coach doesn’t mean they are a poor student any more than taking tennis lessons means they aren’t a good athlete. The point of coaching is to help you improve the abilities you already have, which will then make it easier and more enjoyable to practice the new behavior. You are not unique in having suffered a relapse and it’s not the end of the world.

abstinence violation effect psychology

Inflammatory markers and negative mood symptoms following exercise withdrawal

abstinence violation effect psychology

Short-term abstinence may also have potential as a clinical intervention for behavioral addictions. This review aimed to synthesize existing research evidence on short-term abstinence effects across potential behavioral addictions in light of (1) manifestations of withdrawal, craving and relapse, and (2) benefits or counterproductive consequences of abstinence. We reviewed 47 prospective studies examining effects of short-term abstinence across six potential behavioral addictions (exercise, gambling, gaming, mobile phone use, pornography use, social media use).

Effects and symptoms of deprivation of physical exercise review

Unfortunately, few quantitative, survey-based studies have included substance use during treatment as a potential reason for treatment noncompletion, representing a significant gap in this body of literature (for a review, see Brorson, Ajo Arnevik, Rand-Hendriksen, & Duckert, 2013). Additionally, no studies identified in this review compared reasons for not completing treatment between abstinence-focused and nonabstinence treatment. The AVE was introduced into the substance abuse literature within the context of the “relapse process” (Marlatt & Gordon, 1985, p. 37). Relapse has been variously defined, depending on theoretical orientation, treatment goals, cultural context, and target substance (Miller, 1996; White, 2007). It is, however, most commonly used to refer to a resumption of substance-use behavior after a period of abstinence from substances (Miller, 1996).

Mindfulness-based relapse prevention

Ideally, assessments of coping, interpersonal stress, self-efficacy, craving, mood, and other proximal factors could be collected multiple times per day over the course of several months, and combined with a thorough pre-treatment assessment battery of distal risk factors. Future research with a data set that includes multiple measures of risk factors over multiple days could also take advantage of innovative modeling tools that were designed for estimating nonlinear time-varying dynamics [125]. Initial evidence abstinence violation effect suggests that implicit measures of expectancies are correlated with relapse outcomes, as demonstrated in one study of heroin users [61]. In another recent study, researchers trained participants in attentional bias modification (ABM) during inpatient treatment for alcohol dependence and measured relapse over the course of three months post-treatment [62]. Relative to a control condition, ABM resulted in significantly improved ability to disengage from alcohol-related stimuli during attentional bias tasks.

abstinence violation effect psychology

Although there is some debate about the best definitions of lapse and relapse from theoretical and conceptual levels, these definitions should suffice. The risk of relapse is greatest in the first 90 days of recovery, a period when, as a result of adjustments the body is making, sensitivity to stress is particularly acute while sensitivity to reward is low. It reflects the difficulty of resisting a return to substance use in response to what may be intense cravings but before new coping strategies have been learned and new routines have been established. For that reason, some experts prefer not to use the term “relapse” but to use more morally neutral terms such as “resumed” use or a “recurrence” of symptoms.

Mechanisms of treatment effects